Philosophical Question

Roccus7

Moderator
Staff member
Philosophical Question

Yesterday was destined to be an "off" day considering it the On Again/Off Again bite as of late, and it certainly did not disappoint, me nor two other colleagues. Between the 3 of us, there were 9 or 10 disinterested follow the plug events and one brief hookup. In my normal stubborn mode, I continued fishing as the 2 others heeded the increased volume and frequency of the thunder and headed back to their respective home docks.

Just as the thunder really started booming and I considered it might be prudent to head home, something I was being reminded about since my cell went off with the ring tone from "the Admiral" at fleet operations who was probably telling me that I should be heading home, a huge wake came directly at my plug and Moby Dick just crashed it!! The fish was clearly one of the top 3, if not the biggest I've ever caught since moving to Maine, and after a brief splashing event on the surface of the 4' deep water, it decided it was time to get to deeper water. My boat was directly in the path of that so there I was reeling like a madman, as the fish raced to the boat and once past, it continued running with a screaming drag as fast as possible for a good cast and half past the boat. Since there were no dangerous obstructions anywhere near to me, I even backed off the drag a bit as the fight now turned into the classic slug fest of run 20 or so feet, pump it back, and repeat.

This went on for a good 4 or so minutes and then the battle turned as the runs stopped and it was the endgame of slowly, and carefully gaining the lost line. My heartrate returned to near normal levels and I glanced around to check if the net was within range to grab when needed, and then it happened, I felt the fish roll and the hook pop out!! I won't bore you with the torrent of obscenities that I felt necessary, but the one that comes to mind me was my plaint of Why the F*&K do I do torture myself this way?????

As I do a post mortem of this event, I'm content in that there were no equipment failures, nor angler errors. A failed knot, faulty drag or slack line would have driven me crazy. Further reflection makes me consider that it was close to landing the fish, which has its own set of inherent risk when fishing alone, but after that I would have had to wrestle the fish out of the net, unhook it and then measure it, and consider further things like weighing it and a quick photo, prior to a good 5 minute revival session, as there's no doubt that this was a "way over", probably over the length of my yard stick.

Therefore the philosophical question: should I be grateful as I can rationalize this as a partial win by considering I got the best part of this battling a large fish experience since I was able to enjoy the hunt and ensuing battle, while it won its freedom without extreme, trauma? Alternatively, should I continue to brood over a bitter loss since I was unable to learn exactly how large this fish was?
 
Philosophical Question

Yesterday was destined to be an "off" day considering it the On Again/Off Again bite as of late, and it certainly did not disappoint, me nor two other colleagues. Between the 3 of us, there were 9 or 10 disinterested follow the plug events and one brief hookup. In my normal stubborn mode, I continued fishing as the 2 others heeded the increased volume and frequency of the thunder and headed back to their respective home docks.

Just as the thunder really started booming and I considered it might be prudent to head home, something I was being reminded about since my cell went off with the ring tone from "the Admiral" at fleet operations who was probably telling me that I should be heading home, a huge wake came directly at my plug and Moby Dick just crashed it!! The fish was clearly one of the top 3, if not the biggest I've ever caught since moving to Maine, and after a brief splashing event on the surface of the 4' deep water, it decided it was time to get to deeper water. My boat was directly in the path of that so there I was reeling like a madman, as the fish raced to the boat and once past, it continued running with a screaming drag as fast as possible for a good cast and half past the boat. Since there were no dangerous obstructions anywhere near to me, I even backed off the drag a bit as the fight now turned into the classic slug fest of run 20 or so feet, pump it back, and repeat.

This went on for a good 4 or so minutes and then the battle turned as the runs stopped and it was the endgame of slowly, and carefully gaining the lost line. My heartrate returned to near normal levels and I glanced around to check if the net was within range to grab when needed, and then it happened, I felt the fish roll and the hook pop out!! I won't bore you with the torrent of obscenities that I felt necessary, but the one that comes to mind me was my plaint of Why the F*&K do I do torture myself this way?????

As I do a post mortem of this event, I'm content in that there were no equipment failures, nor angler errors. A failed knot, faulty drag or slack line would have driven me crazy. Further reflection makes me consider that it was close to landing the fish, which has its own set of inherent risk when fishing alone, but after that I would have had to wrestle the fish out of the net, unhook it and then measure it, and consider further things like weighing it and a quick photo, prior to a good 5 minute revival session, as there's no doubt that this was a "way over", probably over the length of my yard stick.

Therefore the philosophical question: should I be grateful as I can rationalize this as a partial win by considering I got the best part of this battling a large fish experience since I was able to enjoy the hunt and ensuing battle, while it won its freedom without extreme, trauma? Alternatively, should I continue to brood over a bitter loss since I was unable to learn exactly how large this fish was?
Great report as I was reading I was getting excited like I was on the boat with you 😂
 
Philosophical Question

Yesterday was destined to be an "off" day considering it the On Again/Off Again bite as of late, and it certainly did not disappoint, me nor two other colleagues. Between the 3 of us, there were 9 or 10 disinterested follow the plug events and one brief hookup. In my normal stubborn mode, I continued fishing as the 2 others heeded the increased volume and frequency of the thunder and headed back to their respective home docks.

Just as the thunder really started booming and I considered it might be prudent to head home, something I was being reminded about since my cell went off with the ring tone from "the Admiral" at fleet operations who was probably telling me that I should be heading home, a huge wake came directly at my plug and Moby Dick just crashed it!! The fish was clearly one of the top 3, if not the biggest I've ever caught since moving to Maine, and after a brief splashing event on the surface of the 4' deep water, it decided it was time to get to deeper water. My boat was directly in the path of that so there I was reeling like a madman, as the fish raced to the boat and once past, it continued running with a screaming drag as fast as possible for a good cast and half past the boat. Since there were no dangerous obstructions anywhere near to me, I even backed off the drag a bit as the fight now turned into the classic slug fest of run 20 or so feet, pump it back, and repeat.

This went on for a good 4 or so minutes and then the battle turned as the runs stopped and it was the endgame of slowly, and carefully gaining the lost line. My heartrate returned to near normal levels and I glanced around to check if the net was within range to grab when needed, and then it happened, I felt the fish roll and the hook pop out!! I won't bore you with the torrent of obscenities that I felt necessary, but the one that comes to mind me was my plaint of Why the F*&K do I do torture myself this way?????

As I do a post mortem of this event, I'm content in that there were no equipment failures, nor angler errors. A failed knot, faulty drag or slack line would have driven me crazy. Further reflection makes me consider that it was close to landing the fish, which has its own set of inherent risk when fishing alone, but after that I would have had to wrestle the fish out of the net, unhook it and then measure it, and consider further things like weighing it and a quick photo, prior to a good 5 minute revival session, as there's no doubt that this was a "way over", probably over the length of my yard stick.

Therefore the philosophical question: should I be grateful as I can rationalize this as a partial win by considering I got the best part of this battling a large fish experience since I was able to enjoy the hunt and ensuing battle, while it won its freedom without extreme, trauma? Alternatively, should I continue to brood over a bitter loss since I was unable to learn exactly how large this fish was?
If you cannot get them to commit, there is no fight, no weigh in, no measure, no picture.

I'll take a commitment on a surface plug any day. That means I gave them what they wanted. Satisfaction.

The real conundrum I see is fishing in the thunder! Safety issue. Fish do bite better during the onset of weather. Do I stay or do I go??
 
If you cannot get them to commit, there is no fight, no weigh in, no measure, no picture.

I'll take a commitment on a surface plug any day. That means I gave them what they wanted. Satisfaction.

The real conundrum I see is fishing in the thunder! Safety issue. Fish do bite better during the onset of weather. Do I stay or do I go??
What song is that, "Do I stay or do I go?"

In my flimsy defense, I was fishing no more than 1,000 yds from the home dock in an area surrounded by 60' tall white pines, not all alone out in the bay or GOM. I even have my VHF antenna in a 1/3 up position so when fishing anchored I can hold my rod high to get a charging fish around the boat without me having to climb up on the bow to move maneuver the fish around.

Besides that, there had been the far off rumble of thunder all morning, and it was just starting to get closer immediately after that fish grabbed the plug so it was one of those, "when Poseidon rips the pole out of my cold, dead hands" events.

Regardless, the storm was still a good ways away, no flashes of lightning visible...
 
Philosophical Question

Yesterday was destined to be an "off" day considering it the On Again/Off Again bite as of late, and it certainly did not disappoint, me nor two other colleagues. Between the 3 of us, there were 9 or 10 disinterested follow the plug events and one brief hookup. In my normal stubborn mode, I continued fishing as the 2 others heeded the increased volume and frequency of the thunder and headed back to their respective home docks.

Just as the thunder really started booming and I considered it might be prudent to head home, something I was being reminded about since my cell went off with the ring tone from "the Admiral" at fleet operations who was probably telling me that I should be heading home, a huge wake came directly at my plug and Moby Dick just crashed it!! The fish was clearly one of the top 3, if not the biggest I've ever caught since moving to Maine, and after a brief splashing event on the surface of the 4' deep water, it decided it was time to get to deeper water. My boat was directly in the path of that so there I was reeling like a madman, as the fish raced to the boat and once past, it continued running with a screaming drag as fast as possible for a good cast and half past the boat. Since there were no dangerous obstructions anywhere near to me, I even backed off the drag a bit as the fight now turned into the classic slug fest of run 20 or so feet, pump it back, and repeat.

This went on for a good 4 or so minutes and then the battle turned as the runs stopped and it was the endgame of slowly, and carefully gaining the lost line. My heartrate returned to near normal levels and I glanced around to check if the net was within range to grab when needed, and then it happened, I felt the fish roll and the hook pop out!! I won't bore you with the torrent of obscenities that I felt necessary, but the one that comes to mind me was my plaint of Why the F*&K do I do torture myself this way?????

As I do a post mortem of this event, I'm content in that there were no equipment failures, nor angler errors. A failed knot, faulty drag or slack line would have driven me crazy. Further reflection makes me consider that it was close to landing the fish, which has its own set of inherent risk when fishing alone, but after that I would have had to wrestle the fish out of the net, unhook it and then measure it, and consider further things like weighing it and a quick photo, prior to a good 5 minute revival session, as there's no doubt that this was a "way over", probably over the length of my yard stick.

Therefore the philosophical question: should I be grateful as I can rationalize this as a partial win by considering I got the best part of this battling a large fish experience since I was able to enjoy the hunt and ensuing battle, while it won its freedom without extreme, trauma? Alternatively, should I continue to brood over a bitter loss since I was unable to learn exactly how large this fish was?
Great outing, although a little hairy with the bad weather coming in. The Bass always seem to like biting better the worse the weather gets.

I would say score this one as a big WIN-WIN for both angler and fish alike!!
 
I'm surprised that in the area you fish with shallow water and smallish bait you don't try using a fly rod.
It's a simple equation...

Fly rod: 6 "wand waves"= 1 fishable cast.

The same number of "waves" with a spinning rod, and you have 6 fishable casts, with double the distance per cast on a good fly cast day, usually closer to 3X, and you don't have to worry about wind velocity!!

I'll drag my 9 wt out when the fish are committing suicide, but they are very few and far between this year, so I want every minute fishing to be as efficient as possible.

If I really want to use the most productive striper fishing shallow water, I'd be dragging Tube-N-Worm rigs, but I'm way too ADD for that...
 
📱 Fish Smarter with the NYAngler App!
Launch Now

Fishing Reports

Latest articles

Back
Top