Spooks & Slurping Stripers - No Mulligans

Roccus7

Moderator
Staff member
Although it pains me, I've added to Spooks to the amory, X-Rap Surface (Herring) and a Rebel Jumping Minnow (Bone). This morning they demonstrated their advantages and disadvantages. The bite started early in the flood, just about the time I could get my boat going without "cleaning" the prop and skeg. There were large groups of fish feeding on small sandeels, subtly breaking the surface all over. After 3 straight casts through the feeding fish with nary a look at my Blueflash Striper Strike, I grabbed the Jumping Minnow and hooked up after missing a few because of short hits and boated a 23" fish. I quickly nailed a 24" fish, but then the bite died. Went off to one of my "Sacred Spots" only to practice casting with every lure known to man with only 1 follow. Was disgusted and started heading back to the barn.

Just as I was ready to make my final approach to my dock float I noticed that the fish were active again in the same area as earlier. Went down there and proceeded to make cast after cast alternating between the Jumping Minnow, the X-Rap and the Creek Chub. Only the 2 spooks elicited any sort of interest, but no substantial hookups. The weakness of the floating lures is that you don't get that second chance of stopping you retrieve if a fish swirls around it to slurp it in. This is deadly with the Creek Chub since it starts to sink the instant you stop your retrieve, and usually the time at which the striper nails them.

This went on for a good 15 minutes and I was really starting to loose my temper, but then reasoned since the fish were feeding on small sand eels, maybe a Chrome Striper Strike was the best choice. Turned out that was the ticket, and I ended my suffering with a beautiful 30", which needed a Mulligan to hook; it hit the plug after I stopped the retrieve immediately following the initial swirl around it. I followed this fish with 4 more including 2, 28" fish, all the fish make me take Mulligans to get them to strike.
 
Very nice adjustment to the fish's preference in presentation. One of the real keys to catching consistently when the bite seems to go south.

Pardn my ignorance, but I know what a Mulligan is when referring to golf. How is this term applied to fishing?
 
Very nice adjustment to the fish's preference in presentation. One of the real keys to catching consistently when the bite seems to go south.

Pardn my ignorance, but I know what a Mulligan is when referring to golf. How is this term applied to fishing?

Just me morphing golf's "Second Chance" to striper fishing. Many times stripers will use a violent swirl to confuse and stun bait and then they'll calmly come back to suck in dinner. With a floating lure like a spook this behavior causes the bass to immediately smell a rat since their meal is still floating and going away. 99% of the time they immediately lose interest in your lure and disappear.

If you're using a sinking topwater like Creek Chub Striper Strike, my go to, one of the most effective techniques is to immediately STOP your retrieve if a bass swirls around it, without making an contact, which voids this technique. 75% of the time they'll grab the plug during this pause, Mulligan #1. If they don't go back to your normal retrieve after an instant, and they may hit it then, Mulligan #2. You still may get another swirl, so you stop again, Mulligan #3, etc.

Extended Mulligan Streaks can often go like this or even longer if you threw a really long cast:
  1. Pop Pop Swirl Stop
  2. Pop Pop Pop Swirl Stop
  3. Pop Pop Swirl Stop
  4. Pop Pop Pop Pop Swirl Stop BAM!!
Of course there can be a very long narrative going on, which in my case is sprinkled with very loud "HIT the F-ing lure!!!"

This technique is absolutely deadly, especially early in the season when the bass are very tentative in their feeding. It is absolutely WORTHLESS with bluefish who will run away from a motionless lure. Back on LI I had to make a split nanosecond decision whether it was a bass or blue going at my lure, but that's no problem up here; I have yet to see a bluefish...
 
Thank you for the very thorough explanation Roccus. It makes perfect sense now and it also reveals why you are so successful in fooling even the most tentative Bass.

You have yet to see a Bluefish!? If it wasn't for keeping the customers rods bent on tough days, I would certainly be happy to have that situation in my backyard!!!
 
📱 Fish Smarter with the NYAngler App!
Launch Now

Fishing Reports

Latest articles

Back
Top