Baked Oyster Recipes...

Roccus7

Moderator
Staff member
When I get huge oysters I like to bake them, like 3 barely fitting on a large dinner plate. I rotate a few recipes including Oysters Rockefeller, but a family favorite is my concoction called "Oysters PhD." There were so named because when I served it to a member of my dissertation committee he commented, "That does it Jack, I'll sign your papers now!! Anyone who can cook like this deserves his doctorate!!" It's a butter-based topping that can also be used for medium sized hard-shells, topnecks or cherrystones.

Ingredients: Garlic, softened salt free butter (1 stick for a dozen large oysters), garlic, 1/4 cup chopped Italian parsley, garlic, 1/2 Italian-style bread crumbs, garlic, 1 TBSP ground up green peppercorns, and did I mention garlic? Actually I use 3-4 large cloves pressed through a garlic press.

Method:
  1. Preheat oven to 375 °F
  2. Shuck oysters pour out most of the liquid and leave flesh in the larger shell. Place them in a metal baking dish
  3. Mix ingredients together and add an equal amount atop each oyster
  4. Bake until edges of oysters start to curl and the butter begins to brown.
That's it, serve with a crusty bread to sop up all that buttery goodness...
 
Finished product...

1549309753217.webp
 
Looks similar to the "Cany Clam" topping with the addition of a heavy dose of garlic, some pepper and parsley ......

Looks great, definitely going to give a try on my next batch of oysters !

(y)
 
Looks similar to the "Cany Clam" topping with the addition of a heavy dose of garlic, some pepper and parsley ......

Looks great, definitely going to give a try on my next batch of oysters !

(y)
Hmmmm

They look great (y)(y)
 
Good lord those are some big oysters!

I don't think I can choke one down raw...but that buttered breadcrumb topping, I can probably put away half dozen. Great job!

They are MONSTAHS!!! Seems like the local oyster farms sell the mongo ones over the winter. They are 3 bite oysters and Lord knows I love raw oysters, but this size is perfect for baking. Whenever I see these "jumbolenes" I have to pick up 1/2 dozen, especially when they're only $1.59 each!!
 
I love Cape May Salts. Every year I go I’m good for a few dozen.

Other than that Kumamoto, Blue Point, etc are great as well.

There’s a restaurant in Portchester right near where the Snowgoose goes out of that has an AMAZING oyster sampler. You get two each of about 7-8 kinds of oysters. Place is called Saltaire.
 
Look for Pemaquids, John's Bay, Glidden Point, Damariscotta River or other Midcoast Maine oysters. Friggin spoiled rotten here, can eat oysters all year since water temps rarely touch 70 °F, EVERY month is an "R" month. The funny thing is that my boat is sitting on a wild bank of Balon Oysters, the European standard. I find them very chalky/tinny in taste and am not a big fan. I adore good old Crassotrea virginica, the American East/Gulf Coast oyster. I keep trying to get them to take root around my dock by dumping my empties there. I'm starting to get a few...

When I lived on LI and collected oysters in both Conscience Bay and Mount Sinai, I would never even think about oysters for eating on the half shell until November through March. If I was cooking them, I'd expand the range from September - April. Now that I've been feasting on cold weather oysters, I can no longer look at oysters South of NJ even during the winter and Gulf Coast Oysters???? Forget 'em, only good for bait!!
 
Look for Pemaquids, John's Bay, Glidden Point, Damariscotta River or other Midcoast Maine oysters. Friggin spoiled rotten here, can eat oysters all year since water temps rarely touch 70 °F, EVERY month is an "R" month. The funny thing is that my boat is sitting on a wild bank of Balon Oysters, the European standard. I find them very chalky/tinny in taste and am not a big fan. I adore good old Crassotrea virginica, the American East/Gulf Coast oyster. I keep trying to get them to take root around my dock by dumping my empties there. I'm starting to get a few...

When I lived on LI and collected oysters in both Conscience Bay and Mount Sinai, I would never even think about oysters for eating on the half shell until November through March. If I was cooking them, I'd expand the range from September - April. Now that I've been feasting on cold weather oysters, I can no longer look at oysters South of NJ even during the winter and Gulf Coast Oysters???? Forget 'em, only good for bait!!

goddamn you've got me pining for oysters lol...
 

Fishing Reports

Latest articles

Back
Top