REELING IN THE RIDICULOUS: America's Most Outlandish Fishing Violations of 2024

george

Administrator
Staff member

When fishing enforcement goes from "catch and release" to "catch and arrest" - these anglers took "bending the rules" to a whole new level

The Great Walleye Weight Scam: When "Heavy Hitters" Took It Too Literally
Walleye Tournament Cheating Scandal


Well, well, well – if it isn't Jake Runyan and Chase Cominsky, the dynamic duo who thought they'd revolutionize competitive fishing by adding a little "extra weight" to their walleye. These two geniuses from Ohio managed to stuff their prized catch with lead weights and fish fillets, turning what should have been a proud moment into a viral sensation that had the entire fishing community doing double-takes.

Picture this: You're at the Lake Erie Walleye Trail tournament, feeling pretty good about your chances, when suddenly the tournament director starts cutting open the winning fish like he's performing surgery. Out pops not one, not two, but EIGHT POUNDS of lead weights! The crowd went from cheering to jeering faster than you can say "That's not how fish anatomy works, fellas!"

The best part? These two brainiacs had been pulling this stunt for who knows how long before getting caught red-handed (or should we say "lead-handed"?) in front of everyone. They ended up with felony charges, $2,500 fines, jail time, and – the real kicker – had to forfeit a $100,000 bass boat. Talk about an expensive fishing lesson! Now they're probably the only anglers in America who can't get a fishing license for three years and have their mugshots plastered on every tackle shop wall from here to Toledo.


The Striped Bass Bandit: When "Limit" Becomes a Suggestion

Striped Bass Fishing Violation


Meet our Massachusetts man with a mathematical problem – apparently, he thought the striped bass limit was more of a "gentle suggestion" than an actual law. This Einstein was caught red-handed with FOURTEEN oversized striped bass off the New Hampshire coast, which is roughly 13 more than anyone with a functioning brain cell would attempt to keep.

The funniest part? This wasn't some sneaky nighttime operation. Multiple anglers witnessed this guy openly keeping fish like he was running a one-man commercial operation, and they promptly called the authorities. It's like robbing a bank in broad daylight while wearing a name tag – bold, but not particularly bright.

New Hampshire Fish and Game officials didn't even have to work hard to catch this guy. They just followed the tips from other anglers who were apparently more familiar with basic fishing regulations than our protagonist. The man was charged with licensing violations and unlawful possession of striped bass, proving once again that sometimes the fish aren't the only ones who get hooked!


The Georgia Hide-and-Seek Champion: Trout Stashing 101

Georgia Game Warden Hidden Fish


Down in Georgia, one enterprising angler decided to turn the Chattahoochee River into his personal trout storage facility. Game Warden Will Gilstrap was just doing his regular patrol when he stumbled upon what can only be described as the world's most obvious fish-hiding scheme. Our amateur magician was literally stashing trout along the riverbank like some kind of aquatic Easter egg hunt gone wrong.

This guy's strategy was about as subtle as a neon sign reading "ILLEGAL FISH STORAGE HERE." He'd catch a trout, hide it somewhere along the bank, then go back to fishing for more. It's like he thought the fish were going to stay fresh sitting in the Georgia sun while he continued his fishing marathon. The warden didn't need Sherlock Holmes-level detective skills to figure this one out – just basic eyesight and common sense.

The best part? When confronted, this river-side entrepreneur probably had to explain why he was treating a public waterway like his personal deep freezer. Game Warden Gilstrap must have had a good chuckle while writing up those citations. Nothing says "I understand fishing regulations" like turning Mother Nature into your walk-in cooler!


The San Francisco False Wall Fiasco: Commercial Fishing Meets Home Improvement

California Commercial Fishing Violation


Leave it to California to produce a fishing violation that sounds like it came straight out of a heist movie. One commercial fisherman at San Francisco's Pier 45 thought he'd get creative with interior design, installing a false wall on his trawling boat to hide over 2,000 pounds of illegally caught fish. We're talking halibut, salmon, sole, and sanddabs – basically everything except a permit to catch them legally.

This maritime mastermind apparently watched too many mob movies and thought, "You know what my fishing boat needs? A secret compartment!" CDFW officers must have felt like they were raiding a speakeasy when they discovered this aquatic treasure trove. Over 2,000 pounds of undeclared fish hidden behind a wall that probably took more effort to build than it would have taken to just follow the regulations in the first place.

The truly hilarious part? All that fish was seized and sold off by CDFW, so at least it didn't go to waste. Meanwhile, our wannabe architect fisherman learned that renovation projects on fishing boats tend to attract the wrong kind of attention from wildlife officers. Next time, maybe stick to legal fishing methods instead of turning your boat into a maritime version of Al Capone's vault!


Remember folks, while these stories are good for a laugh, fishing regulations exist for a reason – to keep our fisheries healthy and sustainable. The real winners here are the fish that get to swim another day thanks to vigilant enforcement officers who keep these would-be fishing bandits in check. So next time you're out on the water, remember: the only thing you should be hiding is your secret fishing spot, not your actual fish!


For more fishing news, tips, and the occasional regulatory comedy show, keep visiting nyangler.com – where the fish stories are real, even when they're unbelievable!
 
The NH bass bust isn't properly represented, but AI wasn't looking at all the facts. Regardless, it highlights the stupidity of MA's commercial regulations, along with ASMFC's enabling of them. MA commercial license holders can catch up to 15 fish on designated days and the MA commercial size limit is a MINIMUM of 35"!! Had he been fishing in MA waters on a designated day his haul would have been totally legit! Oooppps, was I fishing in NH????

Don't get me wrong, I'm glad he got busted, but stuff like this just highlights how ASMFC needs to ensure that any, both recreational and commercial fish regulations are set by AREAS, not by States!! I know my LI friends just adore fishing along the western South Shore to watch the Joisey Boys filling the coolers with fish they would have to toss back.
 
You can't help but jab at our AI angler ;).
Well, he does dish up more than a few hanging curves that need a quick ride into the left center bleachers.
Too many people have abdicated critical thinking, and AI will only accelerate that.

This one was too easy, as it was hashed out many times on other New England-based web sites, and it touched on one of my biggest hot buttons, MA's commercial regulations. How come they can keep key breeders???
 
Well, HAL does serve up more than a few hanging curves that need a quick ride into the left center bleachers.
Too many people have abdicated critical thinking, and AI will only accelerate that.

This one was too easy, as it was hashed out many times on other New England-based web sites, and it touched on one of my biggest hot buttons, MA's commercial regulations. How come they can keep key breeders???
 
📱 Fish Smarter with the NYAngler App!
Launch Now

Fishing Reports

Latest articles

Back
Top