The Missing Fish
198 fish went into the study. 198 fish came out alive.
So where did 9% come from?
In 1996, the Diodati study caught and released 198 striped bass in an artificial pond. Eight weeks later, they drained the pond completely dry. Every single fish they recovered was alive. Not one...
With all due respect my good friend it is a published study. It was published in Marine and Coastal Fisheries, Volume 16, Issue 5, in September 2024. That’s a peer-reviewed journal of the American Fisheries Society.
Here’s the full citation:
Dean, M.J., Hoffman, W.S., Gahagan, B.I., Nelson...
The study is ongoing but here are links to the finding so far.
1. Mass DMF Striped Bass Citizen Science Data Portal (official state data)
https://madmf.shinyapps.io/striper/
2. Mass.gov Striped Bass Research Page
https://www.mass.gov/info-details/striped-bass-research
That’s it. That’s the number. Two.
For thirty years, the entire Atlantic coast striped bass recreational fishery, a multi billion dollar industry and a way of life for millions, has been managed based on the ghosts of fish that never died. But it all started with two. Two small, 13 inch striped...
Roccus, you’re defending a 1996 study where they caught fish and then trucked them for two hours to another location before measuring mortality. You want to talk about flawed methodology? Let’s talk about that.
I’ve been pushing for a new catch and release study for years because I always knew...
I've Been Saying This All Along: Recreational Anglers Deserve an Apology
The data is finally in, and it proves what we've known for years—we were never the problem.
For over a decade, recreational striped bass anglers have been treated like criminals. We've endured slot limits, bag restrictions...
Abu Garcia's Beast Series: Revolutionary Equipment for the Modern Swimbait Revolution
October 2025 marks a pivotal moment in fishing equipment evolution as Abu Garcia introduces their most ambitious tackle series to date. The Beast collection represents a fundamental reimagining of how serious...
Game-Changer or Gimmick? The Daiwa LUVIAS ST Claims to Be the World's Lightest Spinning Reel
An in-depth look at Daiwa's bold claim and what it means for New York anglers targeting trout and panfish
George, as a seasoned angler with homes in both Naples, Florida and Commack, NY, you know the...
Fluke Management in 2025: Regulators Got It Wrong
Halfway through this season New York anglers were slapped with a new rule. The fluke size limit jumped from 19 inches to 19.5. Not because the science demanded it. Not because it helped the fishery. It happened so the season could stretch into...
The Western Run: Hunting Stripers and Blues from Rockaway Beach to Moriches Inlet
By: A Die-Hard Surf Angler
Written from the cab of a Ford F-250, October 2024
The Gritty Truth: Life on the Western Run
It's 3:47 AM and I'm writing this by the dome light of my truck, parked behind the dunes at...
The Eastern Edge: Mastering Montauk to North Fork Waters During the Fall Blitz
By Captain Mike "Truck" Thompson | 30+ Years of Long Island Surf Fishing
Prime Fishing Forecast: October 3-17, 2024
The fog lifts off Montauk Point like a curtain being drawn back, revealing the churning white water...
The Old School Way: A Long Island Sound Blackfish Story
For the party boat angler looking to master the art of catching tautog, sometimes the old ways are the best ways.
The air carries that distinct autumn chill, a signal to seasoned anglers that it's time to shift focus from the fleeting...
New York State Freshwater Fishing Records (Per DEC)
Introduction
These are the current official freshwater state records recognized by the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation under the Angler Achievement Awards Program. If you want to know the biggest bass, catfish, trout, or...
New York State Marine / Saltwater Fishing Records (Per DEC)
Introduction
These are the official marine (saltwater) records recognized by New York DEC under the Marine Recreational Angler Records Program. If you're asking "what's the NY record for bluefish, tuna, striped bass, mahi-mahi, etc.,"...
Unprecedented Albacore Tuna Run Hits Southeast Alaska Waters as Marine Heatwave Creates New Fishing Frontier
Climate-driven warm water intrusion brings southern species 1,500 miles north of normal range
By Staff Writer
September 17, 2025
Jared Nelson, left, and Adam Olson show off their haul...
End of an Era:
Peconic Star Fleet Closes After 43 Years of North Fork Fishing Legacy
A deep dive into the closure that signals broader challenges for Long Island's maritime heritage
GREENPORT, NY — The salt-stained decks of Peconic Star III and Peconic Star IV will no longer echo with the...
We have a ton of fluke here. We see it on this site constantly. If we were allowed an 18-inch fish many would easily limit. I remember a day when a 3-pound fish could make your day. Now a 3-pound fish is barley legal. what they have been through will eventually come here.
There are many things...
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.