Is the Gulf of Mexico a better place to fish overall and fish there in a small boat?

Pangaroo

Angler
Debating whether to buy a winter home on the Gulf side of Florida or on the Atlantic side of Florida. I'm looking at manufactured 55 communities where you own the lot.
One thing that caught my eye , it's pretty shallow in the Gulf out 15 miles or so. Like Long Island depths . Is there Blue Water fishing in the Gulf for Marlin, Mahi Mahi ? The Atlantic side looks really wild, especially the inlets and I'd feel nervous going out in a 25 Foot Panga there. Never fished the Gulf, just the East coast and the Keys. Thanks for any information.
 
The east and west coast of Florida are radically different. On the east coast you go a few miles and you're in 1000 feet of water. On the west coast you need to run 60-70 miles just to get to 100 feet.

Florida experiences different tide cycles on its east and west coasts due to its geographic location and the varying influences of the Atlantic Ocean and the Gulf of Mexico.

On the East Coast of Florida, facing the Atlantic Ocean, the tides typically follow a semidiurnal tide cycle This means there are two high tides and two low tides each day, with approximately equal heights. The Atlantic coast's tides are influenced by the broader Atlantic Ocean's tidal patterns, which are relatively consistent and predictable.

On the West Coast of Florida, facing the Gulf of Mexico, the tide cycle is more complex. The tides generally follow a mixed tide cycle, characterized by a significant difference in height between the two high tides and the two low tides that occur each day, or sometimes the occurrence of only one high and one low tide per day. This mixed tide pattern results from the Gulf of Mexico's shape and depth, as well as the interaction with the Caribbean Sea's tides through the Yucatan Channel. The west coast's tides can vary significantly from place to place and are influenced by local wind patterns and atmospheric pressure changes.

On the East Coast of Florida, the proximity of the Gulf Stream to the shoreline brings a diverse array of pelagic species closer to anglers. This area is renowned for its offshore fishing, offering chances to hook into sailfish, mahi-mahi, wahoo, kingfish, various tuna species, and tarpon. The Gulf Stream’s warm currents create an ideal habitat for these species, making the East Coast a prime location for deep-sea fishing adventures.:

Conversely, the West Coast of Florida, with its access to the Gulf of Mexico, presents a different but equally enticing fishing scenario. The waters here are known for their shallower, warmer conditions, hosting species like snook, redfish, spotted sea trout, and grouper. Boca Grande, often referred to as the “Tarpon Capital of the World,” underscores the region’s reputation for outstanding tarpon fishing. The extensive flats, mangrove estuaries, and offshore reefs and wrecks provide varied habitats that are ideal for inshore and nearshore fishing.

The choice between the East and West coasts ultimately depends on what species an angler is aiming to catch and the type of fishing grounds they prefer to explore. Whether it’s the deep-sea thrills of the Atlantic or the inshore and nearshore diversity of the Gulf, Florida’s coasts offer rich and diverse fishing opportunities.
 
The east and west coast of Florida are radically different. On the east coast you go a few miles and you're in 1000 feet of water. On the west coast you need to run 60-70 miles just to get to 100 feet.

Florida experiences different tide cycles on its east and west coasts due to its geographic location and the varying influences of the Atlantic Ocean and the Gulf of Mexico.

On the East Coast of Florida, facing the Atlantic Ocean, the tides typically follow a semidiurnal tide cycle This means there are two high tides and two low tides each day, with approximately equal heights. The Atlantic coast's tides are influenced by the broader Atlantic Ocean's tidal patterns, which are relatively consistent and predictable.

On the West Coast of Florida, facing the Gulf of Mexico, the tide cycle is more complex. The tides generally follow a mixed tide cycle, characterized by a significant difference in height between the two high tides and the two low tides that occur each day, or sometimes the occurrence of only one high and one low tide per day. This mixed tide pattern results from the Gulf of Mexico's shape and depth, as well as the interaction with the Caribbean Sea's tides through the Yucatan Channel. The west coast's tides can vary significantly from place to place and are influenced by local wind patterns and atmospheric pressure changes.

On the East Coast of Florida, the proximity of the Gulf Stream to the shoreline brings a diverse array of pelagic species closer to anglers. This area is renowned for its offshore fishing, offering chances to hook into sailfish, mahi-mahi, wahoo, kingfish, various tuna species, and tarpon. The Gulf Stream’s warm currents create an ideal habitat for these species, making the East Coast a prime location for deep-sea fishing adventures.:

Conversely, the West Coast of Florida, with its access to the Gulf of Mexico, presents a different but equally enticing fishing scenario. The waters here are known for their shallower, warmer conditions, hosting species like snook, redfish, spotted sea trout, and grouper. Boca Grande, often referred to as the “Tarpon Capital of the World,” underscores the region’s reputation for outstanding tarpon fishing. The extensive flats, mangrove estuaries, and offshore reefs and wrecks provide varied habitats that are ideal for inshore and nearshore fishing.

The choice between the East and West coasts ultimately depends on what species an angler is aiming to catch and the type of fishing grounds they prefer to explore. Whether it’s the deep-sea thrills of the Atlantic or the inshore and nearshore diversity of the Gulf, Florida’s coasts offer rich and diverse fishing opportunities.
Fantastic comparison. Does the Gulf side have patch reefs like in the Keys ? I'd like an area with extensive flats , great for small boat fishing. A couple of Freeport Party boat Capt's retired down on the West Coast, now I know why.Thanks.
 
Hybrid p
Fantastic comparison. Does the Gulf side have patch reefs like in the Keys ? I'd like an area with extensive flats , great for small boat fishing. A couple of Freeport Party boat Capt's retired down on the West Coast, now I know why.Thanks.
If your looking for flats the West coast is the place!
 
George -Would you say you lose more fishing days on the East Coast due to wind and offshore storms than the west coast?
 
@OVERBORED If you asked me that last year I would have said the east coast, but its been blowing on the west coast for what feels like months. The east coast has scary inlets but it's a very short run to the fishing grounds. The west coast has no inlet issues, but it's 60 miles to the offshord grounds.

As I'm answering this I got this text regarding tomorrow's grouper trip: "I think it will be too rough tomorrow Thursday looks good right now if your guys can go then" Now I have to find a crew for Thursday 🤞
 
@OVERBORED If you asked me that last year I would have said the east coast, but its been blowing on the west coast for what feels like months. The east coast has scary inlets but it's a very short run to the fishing grounds. The west coast has no inlet issues, but it's 60 miles to the offshord grounds.

As I'm answering this I got this text regarding tomorrow's grouper trip: "I think it will be too rough tomorrow Thursday looks good right now if your guys can go then" Now I have to find a crew for Thursday 🤞
George, Do Marlin, Mahi Mahi , Tuna swim in close to the shore there at times ? Similiar to what we experience off Long Island ? Thanks.
 

Members online

Fishing Reports

Latest articles

Back
Top